2350 Baltimore Pike
Scroll

A Rare Gettysburg-Area Historic Estate — Lightner Inn & Carriage House Step into history at the extraordinary Lightner Inn, a distinguished Federal-style residence built in 1862 by Sheriff Isaac Lightner and serving as a hospital during the Battle of Gettysburg. Located along Baltimore Pike, just three miles from historic Gettysburg, this remarkable property offers a […]
Description
A Rare Gettysburg-Area Historic Estate — Lightner Inn & Carriage House Step into history at the extraordinary Lightner Inn, a distinguished Federal-style residence built in 1862 by Sheriff Isaac Lightner and serving as a hospital during the Battle of Gettysburg. Located along Baltimore Pike, just three miles from historic Gettysburg, this remarkable property offers a rare opportunity to own a piece of American history. Set on 3.3 acres with an additional 15 acres of partially wooded land, the estate features a total of seven bedrooms and seven baths between the main residence and attached carriage house. Operating as a bed and breakfast since 1998, the property is pristine, move-in ready, and offers exceptional versatility for continued hospitality use or conversion to a single-family residence. Timeless architectural details include original fireplaces, beautiful wood floors throughout, a charming beehive oven, exposed wood beams, a welcoming covered front porch, and a brick walkway that enhances its historic character. The main residence offers inviting gathering spaces, including a parlor, dining room, kitchen, and family room, along with a walkout daylight lower level providing additional flexible space. The attached carriage house features a private upper-level bedroom, bath, and living area, ideal for guests or extended stays. Rich in history, character, and possibilities, this exceptional property is a rare offering in the Gettysburg area, combining historic significance, generous acreage, and timeless charm.
View full listing detailsListing Details
| Price: | $949,900 |
|---|---|
| Address: | 2350 Baltimore Pike |
| City: | Gettysburg |
| State: | Pennsylvania |
| Zip Code: | 17325 |
| MLS: | PAAD2026340 |
| Year Built: | 1862 |
| Square Feet: | 4,652 |
| Acres: | 18.37 |
| Lot Square Feet: | 18.37 acres |
| roof: | Shingle |
|---|---|
| taxLot: | 0014 |
| country: | US |
| lotSqft: | 800197.2 |
| mlsArea: | Mount Joy Twp (14330) |
| netSqft: | 4532 |
| taxYear: | 2026 |
| hotWater: | Natural Gas |
| saleType: | Standard |
| fencingYN: | N |
| heatingYN: | yes |
| soilTypes: | Unknown |
| utilities: | Cable TV Available, Electric Available, Phone Available, Natural Gas Available, Sewer Available, Water Available |
| exclusions: | See Items Included "Exclusions" |
| inclusions: | See Items Included |
| possession: | Settlement |
| coolingFuel: | Electric |
| coolingType: | Central A/C, Ceiling Fan(s), Window Unit(s) |
| heatingFuel: | Natural Gas, Electric |
| heatingType: | Radiant |
| propertyUse: | Owner User |
| sewerSeptic: | On Site Septic |
| waterSource: | Well |
| waterViewYN: | no |
| businessType: | Bed and Breakfast |
| centralAirYN: | yes |
| flooringType: | Slate, Laminated, Wood, Tile/Brick, Carpet |
| lotSizeUnits: | Square Feet |
| municipality: | MOUNT JOY TWP |
| tidalWaterYN: | no |
| waterfrontYN: | no |
| yearAssessed: | 2026 |
| listingLocale: | 200004363630 |
| lotSizeSource: | Estimated |
| showingMethod: | In-Person Only |
| typeOfParking: | Driveway, Parking Lot |
| waterAccessYN: | no |
| displayPriceYN: | yes |
| totalRestrooms: | 7 |
| electricService: | 200+ Amp Service |
| roadSurfaceType: | Paved |
| taxAnnualAmount: | 10047 |
| unparsedAddress: | 2350 Baltimore Pike, Gettysburg, PA 17325-7016, United States |
| waterOrientedYN: | no |
| yearBuiltSource: | Estimated |
| carParkingSpaces: | 8 |
| navigableWaterYN: | no |
| potentialTenancy: | Multiple |
| riparianRightsYN: | no |
| taxAssessedValue: | 590100 |
| vacationRentalYN: | no |
| foundationDetails: | Stone |
| leaseConsideredYN: | no |
| newConstructionYN: | no |
| ownershipInterest: | Fee Simple |
| propertyCondition: | Excellent |
| acceptableFinancing: | Cash, Conventional, FHA, VA |
| accessibilityFeatures: | 2+ Access Exits |
| constructionMaterials: | Brick, Wood Siding |
| internetListingDisplay: | Full Distribution - Yes |
| buildingTotalSqftSource: | Estimated |
| listOfficeBrokerOfRecordKey: | 121155681672 |
| totalGarageAndParkingSpaces: | 8 |
| automaticallyUpdateTaxValuesYN: | yes |
Photos





















































































Data services provided by IDX Broker
Listing courtesy of Sites Realty, Inc. 7173344674